Which is more effective: P Force Extra Super or vacuum devices for ED?

Ronymeran

Member
The effectiveness of P Force Extra Super versus vacuum devices for erectile dysfunction (ED) depends on various factors, including the underlying cause of ED, patient preference, and individual response to treatment. Here is a comparison of the two options:

P Force Extra Super​

P Force Extra Super is an oral medication that contains two active ingredients: sildenafil citrate (100 mg) and dapoxetine (100 mg). Sildenafil citrate is used to treat ED, while dapoxetine is used to treat premature ejaculation (PE).

How It Works:​

  • Sildenafil Citrate: Increases blood flow to the penis, helping to achieve and maintain an erection.
  • Dapoxetine: Delays ejaculation by increasing serotonin levels in the brain.

Benefits:​

  • Convenience: Oral tablets are easy to use.
  • Efficacy: Effective in a significant number of men with ED and PE.
  • Dual Treatment: Addresses both ED and PE, enhancing overall sexual performance.

Drawbacks:​

  • Side Effects: Common side effects include headaches, flushing, nasal congestion, indigestion, and dizziness. Serious side effects may include priapism, sudden vision loss, or hearing loss.
  • Drug Interactions: Not suitable for men taking nitrates or certain other medications.
  • Medical Conditions: Not recommended for men with certain heart, liver, or kidney conditions.

Vacuum Devices (Vacuum Erection Devices - VEDs)​

Vacuum devices are mechanical devices used to help achieve an erection by drawing blood into the penis.

How It Works:​

  • A cylinder is placed over the penis.
  • A pump (manual or battery-operated) creates a vacuum around the penis, drawing blood into it.
  • Once an erection is achieved, a constriction ring is placed at the base of the penis to maintain the erection.

Benefits:​

  • Non-Invasive: No medication needed, reducing the risk of drug interactions and side effects.
  • Immediate Effect: Can produce an erection within minutes.
  • Suitable for Many Men: Can be used by men who cannot take oral ED medications due to medical conditions or drug interactions.

Drawbacks:​

  • Manual Effort: Requires some manual dexterity and preparation.
  • Discomfort: Some men find the constriction ring uncomfortable or painful.
  • Appearance: The mechanical nature of the device may be off-putting to some users and their partners.
  • Maintenance: Requires cleaning and maintenance of the device.

Comparison:​

  • Effectiveness: Both treatments are effective, but their success rates can vary. Oral medications like P Force Extra Super may be more effective for men whose ED is caused by vascular or psychological issues. Vacuum devices are effective regardless of the underlying cause of ED.
  • Convenience: Oral medications are generally more convenient to use compared to vacuum devices.
  • Side Effects and Risks: P Force Extra Super has systemic side effects and potential drug interactions, while vacuum devices have fewer side effects but can cause discomfort.
  • Speed of Onset: Oral medications take about 30-60 minutes to work, whereas vacuum devices can produce an erection in a few minutes.
 
Top