Which insurance ads formats generate real policy leads?

I’ve been thinking about this a lot lately because everywhere you look, there are insurance ads. On websites, on apps, even popping up while you’re reading the news. But I kept wondering, do any of these formats actually bring in real people who want a policy, or are most of them just noise?

The main pain point for me was confusion. There are display ads, search ads, native ads, video ads… and everyone online claims their format is the best. But when you’re actually trying to get leads, it’s hard to tell what works and what just eats budget. I’ve talked to a few people in similar roles, and most of us had the same issue: clicks were coming in, but serious policy inquiries were hit or miss.

So I started paying closer attention to what I was seeing and what I was trying. From my experience, basic banner-style insurance ads looked nice but didn’t always bring strong intent. People clicked out of curiosity and then disappeared. Search-style ads felt more solid because users were already looking for something related to insurance. That alone made the conversations feel more real.

Native ads surprised me a bit. When done in a simple, informational way, they didn’t feel like ads at all. People seemed more relaxed when they landed on the page, which led to better questions and longer sessions. On the flip side, video ads didn’t do much for me. They got views, sure, but very few follow-ups that turned into actual policy discussions.

What really helped was focusing less on flashy formats and more on matching the ad style with user intent. Ads that blended into content or answered a clear question seemed to attract people who were already thinking about insurance, not just browsing. I also noticed that keeping the message simple worked better than trying to explain everything at once.

If you’re still figuring things out, it might help to explore different platforms and formats slowly instead of jumping all in on one. I found some useful background info while reading about insurance ads on this page, which helped me understand how different formats are usually used.

At the end of the day, I don’t think there’s one perfect format. For me, the best insurance ads were the ones that felt natural, showed up at the right time, and didn’t try too hard. Real leads usually come from real interest, not just impressions.
 
Top